Delete, code, agent, or human: how to decide what to automate

Updated

Short answer

Sort every step of a process into one of four buckets. Delete it if it adds no value. Use deterministic code if the rule is clear and the input is structured. Use an AI agent if the input is messy but the result can be checked. Keep a human in the loop if the decision is high-risk, needs judgment, or someone must be accountable. Start with delete, because the cheapest step to automate is the one you remove.

The four buckets

BucketUse it whenExample
DeleteThe step exists only because of an old workaround, or nobody uses its output.A manager re-types data that another system already has.
Deterministic codeThe rule is clear, the input is structured, and the same input always needs the same output.Send the customer a text when a job status changes.
AI agentThe input is unstructured, the task needs reading or writing, and you can check the result.Read a free-text email and fill the fields of a request.
Human in the loopThe decision is high-risk or needs judgment, or a person must own it.Approve a refund over a set limit.

How to sort a step

  1. Ask: why does this step exist? If nobody can say, test removing it. Delete first.
  2. Ask: can I write the rule? If yes, use code. Code is cheaper, faster, and easier to test than an agent.
  3. Ask: can I check the agent's output? If yes, an agent may fit. Write evaluations before you deploy it, and plan how to roll it back.
  4. Ask: what happens if this is wrong? If the cost is high, keep a human. Name the human, the trigger, and the time limit.

Common mistakes

Where this method comes from

We learned this four-bucket framing from Vas, in Greg Isenberg's video “Become a $1M/yr FDE (Full Course).” FDE Workbench uses it in the re-engineer phase: you sort every step of the process you picked and explain each choice, and the rubric scores the reasons.

Questions

When should I use an AI agent instead of code?

Use an agent when the input is unstructured, such as free text or speech, and you can check the result. If you can write the rule, use code.

What does human in the loop mean?

It means a named person reviews or approves a step before it takes effect. A good human-in-the-loop step names the owner, the trigger, and the time limit.

Why delete before automating?

Because a removed step costs nothing to run and cannot fail. Automating a useless step only makes waste faster.